In-Store Pickup Only

Place your order and call us at (614) 762-3557 when you arrive! We will bring your order out to you! Available for pickup Monday – Saturday 11am – 7pm and Sunday 12pm – 6pm.

Signature Flavors

Showing all 7 results

Sort by price: high to low Sort by price: low to high Sort alphabetically

• 

  Cookies ‘N Cream Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  Our gourmet popcorn made with real white chocolate, and Oreo cookies!

  Select options
• 

  Caramel Nut Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  Our caramel popcorn mixed with real pecans. This is one you can go nuts over!

  Select options
• 

  Caramel Peanut Butter Cup Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  If you like peanut butter cups, and you like caramel popcorn, try our Caramel Peanut Butter Cup popcorn. We start with our Signature Caramel popcorn, and coat it with a mixture of real chocolates and creamy Jiff peanut butter.

  Select options
• 

  Dark Chocolate Caramel with Sea Salt Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  Our caramel popcorn covered in real dark chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt. Made fresh daily by hand right in our store.

  Select options
• 

  Midwest Mix Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  A mix of our Signature Caramel popcorn and Cheddar Cheese popcorn.

  Select options
• 

  Signature Caramel Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  Enjoy Fat Baby’s own Signature recipe. Our gourmet popcorn coated in our buttery caramel. Made fresh each day right in our store.

  Select options
• 

  Buckeye Popcorn

  $5.99 – $22.99

  Our take on the traditional Ohio buckeye. Gourmet popcorn coated with creamy Jiff peanut butter and drizzled with real milk chocolate.

  Select options